2007-07-14

Longing the next media? 壹傳媒可持有乎?然。

蘋果日報近期的財經版質量突飛猛進,看來已遠遠超越東方。其中金手指、案內人,還有蘋果批,素質比起信報有過之而無不及。臏雖不能完全同意這些專欄評論的所有觀點,他們敢于挑戰“傳統智慧”,促進本港讀者獨立思考,不畏權威的精神,卻令臏敬佩不已。尤其可喜的是,版面基本上重新容許不同的聲音,少了焦標廖建之流,甚至連無處不在的一些才子都收斂專注,回歸其所擅的搔癢發泄散文。臏本不看財經專欄,最近不得不刮目相看。終極奧運概念股之說,我是完全同意的,因此先此申報利益:"this author has no financial interest in the next media group at this point of time. however, this author is considering to become an individual shareholder of the group."

'罵者愛也',就像老鼠愛大米,oops,說錯了,應該說就像港女罵港男。所以臏也特別愛罵蘋果,固在此提一些意見:
  • 是不是能客觀一點的報道貴報老板宗教的新聞?是不是可以在這方面真正地做到編審自由?
  • 像昨天的《政治市》的跳躍思維,是否可以減少一點?拜托,請不要把財經評論淘潔化,好不好?

---

注:《政治市》主要借了Fortune雜志一編質量不高的報道,Gates in China,進行其跳躍性的“論證”。Fortune的‘真知灼見’,及其預測能力,已是有目共睹。微軟在中國的戰略,一般認為是有計劃的(1),而且是非常成功的。這之中涉及了如何在外在環境改變(版權無法得到保護、價格策略需要重新評估等)了的情況下的應變,并從而最大化其長遠商業利益。這恰恰就是HBR, Mckinsey Quarterly 探討的問題。也是新媒體時代(特別是與版權法、BT、網上媒體相關領域)的一個重要案例。

該文中提到有關國內的一些問題,都是事實,卻都與微軟的成功和失敗關系不大。也并非能左右眾多在內地投資的港商的成功的因素。而文中關于"歷史任務消失"的討論也是對的,不過這只意味著既有競爭優勢的消失而已。

在穩定成熟的市場,需要HBR和Mckinsey Quarterly的地方不多。在內地這世界上變化最快,競爭最激烈的市場,戰略的考量才有其用武之地。至于所謂的“十七大與胡錦濤時代 ,中南海秘聞等等”,那是給炒消息股的財經演員看的,不是實實在在做生意人需要的。借張五常的說法,大陸開放27年,若以政治市為主,不可能有今天的成績。

(1)Fortune原文:“Today Gates openly concedes that tolerating piracy turned out to be Microsoft's best long-term strategy. That's why Windows is used on an estimated 90% of China's 120 million PCs. "It's easier for our software to compete with Linux when there's piracy than when there's not," Gates says. "Are you kidding? You can get the real thing, and you get the same price." ”

2007-07-13

Mapping China's provinces



Where have I been and where should I visit next?
Map creator here for Chinese provinces, (then right click to save image) via WXF




For the world map: Blue=Have been, Green=want to, Dark brown= have lived

2007-07-11

The economics behind flight attendents: 侍者与空姐

看到有關侍者與空姐的討論,最近沸沸揚揚。

筆者也曾常年是魚翅公司的鑽卡會員,只是最近由于魚翅公司的盧溝會社(marco polo club)太摳,才轉到北京奧運同盟(one world one dream)的美航去,由是藍寶卡以上,則所有同盟公司里程一律雙計。因此,我想我應該有資格來說兩句吧。

先為侍者說句公道話。控辯雙方須各打五十大板。首先,侍仔(者)是否一個很失禮的職業?為何先受尹君奚落,後為空服菲薄?當然,空服并不只是會說外語會飛的侍者,空中安全應變訓練等,還有不少要求。尹君所言,空服職業生命較短,因此NPV或比侍者還低,也不完全正確。只要能放棄歧視,放下架子,空服員退役後起碼也可重新當侍者吧?

扯遠了,回歸正題。各位應該記得,昔,魚翅之空服員,以菲泰印籍居多。千禧以降,魚翅管理因應市場調研,逐步把空服轉回港女港男主導。這其中包括經濟原因。蓋90年代以降,本港工資有升無降,外籍員工成本低廉。以相同的工資,可以聘得外籍空服的能力、外表、敬業態度皆有過之而無不及。而且員工流失率也低。若非碰上建華之亂,使得本港工資一落千丈,魚翅未必有機會改變其空服招聘策略。

實話實說,換回本地空服,感覺的確是親切多了。可是,服務質量態度的問題,也隨之而來。港女港男在魚翅當空服員的工資與原籍地(香港)其他工作機會的工資的距離比率,比起菲印泰籍空服的低多了。魚翅付出的溢價(premium - 所獲人才的能力高于所付薪資)不高,當然不能奢望獲得同樣的服務質量。近幾年魚翅的頭等倉服務,比起911前的商務倉還不如。最近幾年的商務倉服務,也是參差不齊。有朋友反映,連空姐的姿色也如是。這指的是平均大略,例外當然不缺。

可是說句公道話,魚翅的空服水平,還是世界一流的。要飛歐美,除了魚翅,不作二選。難道要我去受那些聯航奶奶(Untied Nana)們的氣?不過,在亞洲市場,情況可不一樣了,港龍新航的服務,非常穩定,貫切始終比起魚翅有過之而無不及。國內的南航國航東航,也逐步趕上。特別是南航。只可惜港龍給鯊魚一口吞去,不留痕跡。即使對個人來說,來年港龍里程也可以累積了,壟斷對我們消費者從來不是甚麼好事。

亞洲航空公司的服務水平相對高,也有其經濟原因。發展中國家工資普遍較低,造就了上述的空服員溢價,使得亞洲航空公司輕易獲得最好的員工。歐美公司,由于工會的阻撓,根本不可能外聘空服(一些國外航線部分配額例外)。加上空服員的薪酬資歷,一般以飛行里數時間算,資歷老的員工有優先選擇輪班的權利(長途航班多為所占),沒有升遷努力的積極性,結果如何,坐過臭名昭張的聯航的,“有口皆碑”,有目共睹。英航的頭等艙空服員,全是白發蒼蒼年逾花甲的老太太。雖然英航的頭等服務態度比美國公司的好多的,比起英航的商務倉也有天淵之別,不過怎么忍心對這些老太太作過分的要求?

除了薪酬的溢價,眾所皆知的是旅游見識溢價了。在較窮的國家地區,出外旅游的費用相對收入水平為高,使得空服員更增加了一層無形的溢價。七、八十年代的香港大概如此。可是,當旅游不再是富裕階層的專利,空姐職業也失去往日的光環了。這個行業,也失去了它往昔固有的吸引力。香港的今天,就是這種情況。

說了這麼些故事,實在是要為我們的魚翅公司提點建議:
  • 放棄大量招聘本地空服員的策略。航空公司投資與空服身上的培訓很高,一般都有數月培訓才能上機。一次員工流失的成本很高。估計魚翅的本地空服員流失率遠高于來自其他東南亞的員工。
  • 若為了語言膚色的親切感,可以考慮到國內(甚至廣東)去招考,以魚翅航空的待遇,要多漂亮有多漂亮,要多英俊有多英俊,服務態度更是不用費心。君不見,國內餐館的服務態度早已超越香港,乃全世界最最好的。可憐的是民工侍者,備受頤指氣使,一聲也不敢吭,而且培訓不足,侍者犯錯非戰之罪,那是題外話
  • 有了這些競爭優勢,是不怕比不上歐美公司的。我認識的老外,除了沒見識過亞洲公司服務水平的,沒有不是以魚翅新航為首選的
  • 說到國內的東航國航,目前在共用航線上的占有率遠落后于歐美競爭對手。因此航班對開權利是對等的,不過國內公司并不能開足。假如國航魚翅,東航新航這些聯盟鞏固了,則國內公司的飛安地勤空服水平得以改善,隨時可以把中美和中歐航線的競爭局勢逆轉。這才是這幾家公司長遠的價值所在,也是一眾投資者所該留意之處。

2007-07-10

Good writing is not very conducive to good logic




人前人後,高下立見

Why these smart people talk (/write) like idiots? They certainly are not. Do they think we are idiots? Are they trying to insult us?

Cheung Man Yee (see below) may win the Eulogy Prize of the year with this, but as "the saying" goes, Good writing is not very conducive to good logic.

Ms Cheung, this is not about "Good night and good luck". Let Simon or Roland run RTHK. Either one of them has much better sense than you or Mr Chu. Or, consider the Golden commentator who said,


  • 「 點 解 老 細 去 滾 , 港 台 員 工 會 話 打 擊 士 氣 … … 上 司 出 醜 , 正 常 計 , 成 個 Office 都 笑 唔 停 就 真 , 應 該 係 士 氣 大 振 。 」 ─ ─ 到 此 一 遊 ( 高 登 討 論 區 )

This is not about the morale of RTHK, or the staff of RTHK. It is the morale of those who support the continuing independent operation of RTHK receiving full funding from the government.


I am not sure why RTHK must not be privatized. The way Mr Chu adn RTHK repsonded to this media fiasco has a lot to do with the culture of such a white elephant. In a commercial company, this will not happen.


My view on the RTHK controversy is quite simple.


Privatize RTHK, make it a commericial company, supported by advertisement/etc. Allow it to be operated like Commerical Radio, while reducing its funding by 25% (or 33%) per year. OR simple sell it through an open auction



---

張 敏 儀 致 港 台 員 工 信 件 全 文 如 下 :

致 港 台 同 事

連 日 來 我 們 驚 訝 、 痛 心 , 為 朱 培 慶 擔 心 , 也 擔 心 港 台 形 象 受 損 , 擔 心 士 氣 受 打 擊 、 擔 心 失 去 市 民 支 持 。 但 今 天 朱 培 慶 作 出 了 決 定 , 以 他 一 貫 的 紳 士 風 度 , 衣 袖 一 揮 , 不 再 糾 纏 下 去 。

我 們 不 說 「 退 一 步 海 闊 天 空 」 這 種 空 話 , 人 誰 無 過 ? 朱 培 慶 用 漂 亮 的 英 文 說 “ Alcohol is not very conducive to good behaviour. ” 我 笑 了 , 寬 慰 地 笑 了 。 我 們 的 處 長 還 是 見 得 人 的 。 他 向 記 者 說 “ Drink less ( 少 喝 烈 酒 ) . ” , 咀 角 帶 一 絲 微 笑 , 正 是 天 涼 好 個 秋 。

下 一 步 , 向 前 看 。 再 說 一 次 : 做 好 節 目 才 是 我 們 的 本 份 。 有 一 支 筆 、 一 個 咪 、 一 部 攝 影 機 , 還 有 一 個 心 、 一 個 腦 , 做 好 本 份 , 一 定 繼 續 得 到 支 持 。

香 港 電 台 已 經 是 一 個 機 制 , 一 個 信 念 , 也 是 一 國 兩 制 的 象 徵 。 曾 經 參 與 , 繼 續 參 與 , 都 值 得 珍 惜 。 大 家 不 會 忘 記 朱 培 慶 的 貢 獻 , 一 定 有 機 會 江 湖 再 見 。

Good night, and good luck!

張 敏 儀

2007-07-08

Back to basic - give back 3G what 3G was designed for

Hutchison's 3G finally decided to face the reality, to sell 3G as what it should be, i.e. mobile data transmission... and was rewarded by its customers, and shareholder's.

Stories has that back in the crazy era of 1999-2000, every major strategy consulting firm has been engaged in the bidding 'strategy' for the 3G license in Europe. The business was so good that some prestigeous firm worked for 2 rival consortia for the same bid. Of course, there were Chinese Walls among the teams and the teams worked from different cities.

A few months after the bid, people met and were allowed to talk about the non-sensitive details in the aftermath. The valuation from the two teams turned out to be about 10 times apart, based on completely different assumption of which level of the value chain the operator can capture.

Of course, we now know which team did the best service to its client. For the winning consortium, the difficult choice is to redo its business plan and recognize the reality. it took more than 7 years for Hutchison to do so, but it is better late than not getting there.

2007-06-27

Great posts - and critical thinking in HK

I have not updated my reading list for a while. The mainly reason is that I have been too busy these days, no time to read, no time to put the link even if I had read.

However, if you note the upper right corner of my blog, you could still see that I have updated the readling list from time to time.

Today, there were 2 great posts (both in Chinese) that I would like to recommend. I had wanted to write about these 2 issues for quite some time, and am glad that I do not have to now. There are some critical writers in HK.

1) The ugly fact under the Education Institute Controversy
2) Is Christine Luk stupid, or ?

The first post by Yellow Cow is perhaps THE best analysis I have read in HK media recently, published on Apple Daily today. It revealed the ugly dirty secret of the Professional Teachers' Association in Hong Kong, led by democrat Chueng Man Kong, and addressed almost all the problems of the education system in HK just in about 1000 words. It is simply a brilliant summary of all you need to know about HK. (But beware of this yellow cow, most of the other time he acts like a Bush mouth piece / WSJ Op-ed propaganda machine)

The second link about some ridiculous propaganda from a HK think tank, headed by democrat Christine Luk. Ms Luk is a British trained lawyer, and also a veteran commodity trader who traded commodity perhaps before the famed Apple Daily Petroleum Analyst Pakman was born. :). She is definitely not stupid. So why did she made such an obvious mistake? What is her motive?

So much noise, and I thought no one would speak out in HK. I am glad that the people in HK are not all blind and have cirtical minds.

Lastly, talking about local media, on Tuesday's column (June 26 - I have the pdf format but do not know how to convert into jpg or post here - please advise) Lam Hang-chi of HK Economic Journal wrote about the (pseduo)-"coincidence" that many great economists are trained in some other disciplines, mostly in maths or physics. I do have one theory, viz, undergraduate economic textbooks are simple dull and boring. It is hard for such course to attract the brightest minds. I sat in a few undergraduate economic classes at one of the very top Ivy League college taught by star professors, I wanted to sleep. I tried to read Economic textbooks, I never really gone pass the demand/supply curve chapters.

Lam made a small factual error though. He said the only couple that both won Nobel prize is Mr and Mrs Myrdal, in Economic and Peace. Not true. Mr and Mrs Curie shared the Physics Prize in 1903. In fact the Curie family collect 4 medals together. Lam also forgot the now famous John Nash, who is not only not trained as an economist, but never been a real economist.

Now really lastly, The is a quote for the critical minds, including to the 2 writers in the posts above, who dare to speak out against the mediocre minds. By our dear friend Albert,

p.s.
1) There are quite a number of thing I do not agree with these writers/bloggers. For example, the plastic bag tax controversy. But I admire the fact that they are rational and can think and shout despite the mediocre noise over the atmosphere in HK
2) I am glad that Apple Daily is courageous enough to publish these 2 great essays on the same day, both are critical of Jimmy Lai's political allies, the democrats. Kudos to Mr Lai, or more precisely, the AD editor. I have to say, AD has recovered from the Liu Kinming fiasco and regained credibility and my respect. I am sure it will be much more effective media to achieve whatever Mr Lai wants to achieve, by being rational, fair, factual, and balanced.
3) To illustrate why it is important to read critically, read this timely link via ESWN.

2007-06-26

Juxtaposition: We are all _______

Here is the juxtaposition

A) Kill Us, Too: We Are Also Americans
B) Kill Us, Too: We Are Also Al Qaeda (Get a salon site pass and click on this link again)

Except that,
1) it took millions of Americans - the great men who wrote the constitution, Abraham Lincoln, millions who died in the two world wars to liberate the world - more than 200 years to win the good will of Mr. Aslam Abdullah to say (A), voluntarily.
2) it took just a few cone-heads from Washington to -- to force the 27.6M Iraqi, and potentially much more in the neighboring countries to say (B), involuntarily, but they were given no other option

Can't find our enemy? create some so that we have a war to fight. This is the dreamland for arms dealers.

How was Sun Zi taught in West Point? Go figure.

"Take Advantage Of Employment Discrimination"

China Law Blog has a very interesting post: Take Advantage Of "China's Rampant Employment Discrimination"

Well, I would say, "Take Advantage Of Employment Discrimination", anywhere in this world that there is discrimination. Though I also agree with CLB that it is indeed rampant in China -- just look at the unisex restaurants and unisex factory floors (even though one could argue that there is cost reduction due to easy management for unisex factory, i doubt if the benefit outweighs the cost).

There are, however, a couple points to add
  • CLB said, 'Another discrimination in China is against "villagers" without a degree from one of China's top two or three universities. Another opportunity.' -- I do not quite agree. First, we see the same brand premium in US (Ivy Leage and Stanford) and UK (Oxbridge) and the average quality from the premium brands are indeed higher. Second, it is true that there are 'arbitrage' opportunity from the "villager" graduates, but this is not without costs, i.e., more time to select the right candidate due to lower average success rate. But I do agree with CLB, if you spot one, grab him! (Digression: the beauty of the Chinese language is that there was no gender in the 3rd person - "彼or 他", until the turn of last century during May-4 movement when "它/她" were created, plus the ridiculous 牛也 (the god belongs to the gender of cow!). Anyway, we used to enjoy the absence of stupid political correctness in terms of "him/her" or "s/he" or "chairperson". If you understand 禅(Zen in Japanese) or heard about the story of 3 monks bumped into a nude girl, you would understand what I mean.)
  • Yes, there is arbitrage if one does not discriminate, because the cost of recruitment is lower (one finds the right candidate quicker, statistically). However, if one is going to pay the same amount for others, one is not exploiting the arbitrage fully. To exploit the arbitrage fully one would only have to pay a small premium over the market rate, which is usually still lower than what the "true" value of the candidate is. This does solve one major problem, i.e., the case when some are unemployed due to discrimination
  • I know what I said above in politically incorrect, but that is the reality of this world. However, without facing the reality one cannot really address the problem. We need to recognize that, even if one would still partially discriminate these candidates, the important thing is that we realize the TRUE value of these people. Once this is realized, one would expect more employers will join the arbitrage competition, and gradually bid up the price. The point of inflexion is when the underpivileged receives more than one job offer. To make this happen we need more employers who are willing to just pay a very small premium (or even no premium) over the current (under-rated) market price. Until, eventually or asymptotically, when there is no more arbitrage opportunity. Then the CLB mission will be accomplished.
  • Therefore, even for those employer who are still paying a discount to the discriminated (but just the smallest premium over the market rate), we should encourage them and encourage more employers to follow suit. Because that is the first step toward the ultimate goal, and one must go through such first step in the long process of transition.
  • The fundamentalist would criticize those who pay a small (but not enough) premium for not doing enough. I need to warn them, they are effectively hurting the discriminated they claim to protect.

Again, this applies not just to China. It applies to any other country, developed or developing. It is actually the theme of one of my old post -- China vs India. And again, the situation in China, albeit may not be the worst in this world (there are many countries that are worse), is not an excuse. It is for China's own good if this problem gets solved, even if it is partially. The larger the extent this partial solution is, the more competitive China as a nation will become.

2007-06-21

Reading: Hong Kong's 5* academic mess

探 針 : 「 沒 有 我 們 , 那 有 今 天 ? 」

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

香 港 回 歸 以 前 , 英 國 首 相 戴 卓 爾 夫 人 否 認 背 棄 香 港 人 , 她 並 為 英 國 帝 國 主 義 辯 護 道 : 「 我 們 把 文 明 帶 給 全 世 界 ! 」 回 歸 日 告 別 演 說 中 查 理 斯 王 子 說 : 「 香 港 的 歷 史 是 我 們 的 一 部 份 , 反 之 亦 然 。 」 末 代 港 督 彭 定 康 形 容 香 港 是 「 具 有 英 國 特 色 的 、 偉 大 的 中 國 人 成 功 的 故 事 」 ( 好 幾 個 「 的 」 ) 。 回 歸 後 , 香 港 的 痛 苦 指 數 隨 老 董 陡 升 , 直 到 北 京 回 頭 用 彭 定 康 的 門 徒 氣 溫 才 回 暖 。

滬 商 治 港   絕 非 偶 然
這 豈 不 活 生 生 印 證 了 薩 伊 德 在 《 文 化 與 帝 國 》 模 仿 殖 民 者 口 說 的 話 : 「 你 們 有 今 天 , 全 靠 我 們 ; 沒 有 我 們 , 你 們 就 得 回 到 蠻 荒 狀 態 ! 」
英 國 帝 國 主 義 把 它 要 的 不 要 的 人 , 要 的 不 要 的 制 度 , 統 統 送 做 堆 , 給 了 香 港 照 單 全 收 。 沒 有 「 英 國 特 色 」 沖 刷 封 建 的 毛 式 「 中 國 特 色 」 , 今 天 的 香 港 會 不 會 像 二 十 年 前 的 海 南 島 那 樣 「 先 進 」 ?
記 得 回 歸 前 一 兩 年 , 洪 清 田 兄 做 東 請 一 桌 好 飯 , 一 圈 人 輪 流 猜 誰 會 出 線 當 第 一 任 特 首 。 我 脫 口 預 測 , 是 個 「 滬 商 治 港 」 的 局 面 。 不 是 我 懂 得 掐 指 一 算 , 而 是 想 到 港 英 工 心 計 , 有 套 路 , 讓 港 人 那 麼 服 帖 , 而 中 國 人 信 奉 「 拿 來 主 義 」 , 任 錢 其 琛 、 魯 平 、 張 浚 生 嘴 巴 再 硬 , 祖 國 實 在 沒 有 理 由 不 繼 承 港 英 的 深 刻 遺 產 。 當 時 我 腦 中 的 影 子 是 港 大 和 中 大 : 港 大 這 個 殖 民 官 搖 籃 的 校 長 寶 座 , 長 期 由 英 國 人 包 辦 , 直 到 晚 期 南 洋 華 裔 才 有 機 會 過 癮 ; 中 大 前 幾 任 校 長 多 與 上 海 有 淵 源 , 又 有 香 港 和 倫 敦 的 育 背 景 。 如 此 巧 合 , 絕 非 偶 然 。 因 此 我 猜 首 任 特 首 是 「 滬 」 和 「 商 」 的 組 合 。


華 裔 學 者   紛 紛 回 流
香 港 各 大 學 一 方 面 從 全 世 界 公 開 招 聘 師 資 , 另 一 方 面 又 處 處 有 「 把 文 明 帶 給 世 界 」 的 遺 跡 。 以 前 有 句 名 言 : 「 在 倫 敦 一 事 無 成 , 到 香 港 碰 碰 運 氣 」 。 從 倫 敦 到 香 港 , 石 頭 就 點 成 了 金 。 英 語 世 界 美 加 澳 印 各 路 人 馬 ( 也 就 是 比 香 港 更 早 獲 得 「 解 放 」 的 英 國 殖 民 地 ) , 來 香 港 搵 食 者 , 絡 繹 不 絕 於 途 。 跟 華 裔 學 者 紛 紛 從 美 英 回 流 。 這 就 構 造 了 香 港 各 大 學 的 風 景 線 。
朋 友 自 海 外 歸 來 , 踏 進 自 稱 「 五 星 級 」 的 系 。 那 個 系 成 員 從 五 湖 四 海 漂 來 , 開 起 會 來 只 聽 到 英 語 「 呱 呱 叫 」 , 英 文 是 否 出 色 比 較 難 說 。 這 些 人 有 話 爭 講 , 有 事 拼 命 躲 , 從 無 新 意 , 更 乏 建 樹 。 但 他 們 關 起 門 來 , 互 拍 肩 膀 讚 好 , 聽 久 了 很 難 不 把 自 己 當 一 回 事 。 直 到 有 一 天 外 人 闖 進 「 桃 花 源 」 , 定 神 一 看 , 原 來 是 一 群 母 雞 帶 小 雞 的 大 院 : 徒 子 徒 孫 , 幾 代 同 堂 , 老 爸 退 而 不 休 , 再 由 子 女 接 棒 , 肥 水 不 落 外 人 田 , 近 親 繁 殖 達 於 極 致 ; 更 有 的 找 隔 壁 同 事 當 導 師 , 毋 須 修 課 , 胡 亂 寫 一 篇 甚 麼 東 西 , 居 然 鍍 金 成 為 「 博 士 」 。 學 問 大 躍 進 了 , 卻 老 不 發 表 學 術 論 文 。 朋 友 說 , 這 座 「 桃 花 源 」 風 景 好 , 何 止 「 五 星 級 」 , 評 它 「 八 星 級 」 絕 不 為 過 。 不 知 有 漢 , 遑 論 魏 晉 , 別 處 的 確 沒 有 見 過 。

李 金 銓
城 市 大 學 教授

2007-06-17

Superboys in Taiwan -- Super Avenue of Stars

Sorry, too busy to blog. But I would recommend this post by Sidekick.
溏心風暴的星光大道 (ESWN translation in English)
Related: How Pfizer's Viagra sales skyrocketed in HK

Supergirl finally got a sequel. It is called "Super Avenue of Stars", a similar singing contest in Taiwan, produced by Huang Zongwei, the producer of the celebrated Mengguo.

The key element that deviates from Supergirl is that in SAS there is a challenger session, where the challenger can pick one of the finalists and replace him. The germ in SAS is that there is a really good challenger, who is arguably as good as or even better than the best incumbent. He chose to fight the toughest battle, by choosing to challenge the incumbent leader and sing the song the incumbent has sang, winning 2 round before lost in a controversial final round of challenge, and -- you got it right, CRIED! That was a touching scene. The common theme for the Supergirls and Superboys is that they all like to cry.

Because of this show, an old song became a new hit in Taiwan.






The preliminary round of challenge


---
Mengguo is quick to spoof






There is more in Taiwan than corrupted politicians, political bickering, or dumb money diplomacy. It is still a beautiful island.